Today’s column is my pitch for playing in PTQs. If you’re already a PTQ regular, I encourage you to read it and share your thoughts about why you play in PTQs. I’d also encourage you to share the column with your friends who have not, for one reason or another, been interested in playing at a PTQ. If you’re new to the idea of going to a PTQ, then I hope this column sheds some light on why I love them.
Last week I attended a talk by Daniel Pink, where he spoke about his new book, Drive. Drive is about the things that really motivate us, and how businesses can use those motivations to increase productivity. He collects the results of years of behavioral research that tell us that when we get past the basic needs (e.g. food), what really drives us is not punishment and reward but autonomy, mastery, and purpose. I’ll let you read the book if you really want to know more, but the upshot is that we truly perform when we get to choose what we want to do, get to do better at it, and do it for some reason greater than “I’m going to get paid.”
I mention this because as we venture deeper into a PTQ season, we’re often awash in the assumption that each and every step is its own gold ring. We want to win a PTQ because we want to go to the Pro Tour, and we want to go to the Pro Tour because we want to win the Pro Tour.
Is it the money? Although winning the top prize at a Pro Tour and taking home whatever fraction of $40,000 you’re left with after taxes would certainly be welcome, I can assure you that there are better ways to spend your time than trying to make it onto the Tour and trying to win an event if you’re out to make $40,000. The expected value, as we are fond of saying, of entering a PTQ is a very, very small portion of that $40,000.
If each win is not an end in itself, then it’d be good if we could avoid having a blank look on our faces when a fellow Magic player asks us why they should consider going to a PTQ.
My pitch for PTQing is very simple.
PTQs are fun.
I say this because it’s true, but I also say it because I get the impression that Magic players who aren’t PTQ regulars think it’s nearly the exact opposite of fun. If all they’re ever told is that “you could get on the Pro Tour,” I think it’s reasonable that they’d never want to go.
So why do I think they’re fun?
Community is fun
PTQs plug you into your local and not-so-local “competitive” player community. If you’re able to make it to a PTQ in a reasonably large metropolitan area, you can expect to meet a hundred or more like-minded people who are all there at the same time for the exact same event. If you’re used to playing with your casual group or a local play club, or perhaps your favorite game store’s FNM, you may be interacting with maybe a couple dozen people at most. A PTQ is your opportunity to meet and enjoy the company of a lot of people you wouldn’t otherwise have access to.
Our local PTQs are large enough that in a few years of attending them, I’ve rarely played the same person twice. As a consequence, I typically begin each match by asking the person their name (hint – do this to be friendly, and to make sure the person sitting across from you is the person you saw yourself paired with on the pairings sheet) and where they’re coming from.
You may be surprised at just how far people have come to attend the PTQ. We regularly see traffic between the Bay Area and Southern California for PTQs, which can mean trip of four or five hundred miles each way. People from California also make their way to Seattle and Las Vegas for PTQs. I’ve vicariously expanded my knowledge of California geography just by running into people who come from towns I hadn’t heard of before.
The other thing I started doing about a year ago is asking my opponent “what they do.” Given the demographics of Magic, I expected the default answer to be “I’m a student,” but the scope has been pleasingly wide on this one as well. I’ve met people who do car customizations, software developers at Yahoo, and a plumber from whom I learned that plumbing is a seasonal job (because in Spring people realize their pipes are leaking, and the tree in their back yard has broken their sprinklers).
When your match ends each round, you’ll notice that players are watching other matches, or just hanging around and talking. The break between each match and the next is an opportunity to share stories about your day so far, to scout the room, or to just settle down next to a particularly interesting match that’s still going. The corollary to this is that if you’re playing an interesting deck or if your match has simply gone long, you should expect to end up with an audience.
My chief advice here is to remember that you are at a competitive event, so don’t talk about the match where the players can hear you. Don’t give advice, don’t comment on the board state or someone’s draw. This may sound silly, but I’ve had it done to me and I’ve seen people do it while spectating. If you think you see an error that actually violates the game rules, you are allowed to ask the players to stop and call a judge. Otherwise, just watch, enjoy, and don’t cringe visibly when one of the players makes a horrible misplay that you never would have made. It happens.
So what about those “competitive” players? Won’t they make the day horribly unfun?
I won’t lie. There will be some annoying people at any large event, whether it’s a PTQ or a rock concert. However, “annoying” and “competitive” are not synonymous. At one of our PTQs last year, you might have been paired up with David, Josh, or Jeremy. They’re all competitive and they’re all perfectly nice people.
In fact, this segues into my next point
Technically strong play is fun
Let’s return for a moment to Daniel Pink’s book Drive. One of the elements he mentioned that motivates us is mastery. Mastery means, roughly, “getting better at stuff.” It’s fun to get better at stuff, and it’s fun to watch people who are skilled do their thing.
I’ve read a lot of discussion about competitive play by people who don’t spend a lot of time doing it. The most common complaint is that the competitive player doesn’t “just have fun.” The idea built into this assertion is that Magic is more fun when you allow takebacks, sloppy play, and maybe don’t play with some of the cards that you don’t like (e.g. counterspells). By this standard, a PTQ would necessarily be intrinsically unfun.
Naturally, I disagree.
The reason I love going to PTQs is because I know that my opponents will have brought their “A” game. Their game (and mine) may or may not be enough to win the tournament, but I like going to an event where I know that each person I play against will have brought the best deck they could bring and will be playing the best game they can play.
As a consequence, when you win a game, you get to know that you’ve done a genuinely good job. Similarly, when you lose, you’ll get a chance to see a well-built deck being played with actual skill. Then, in between rounds, no matter how you’re doing you can go watch the top tables and see the best players in your PTQ community facing each other down.
If you enjoy watching the Wizards live video coverage of Pro Tour top eights, or you’ve been keeping up with the work ggslive has done in the last year, imagine getting to do the same thing, in person – and as a participant! Although it may be initially disconcerting to take that step outside of your own pool of players and whatever house rules you’re used to, the fact that you can go to this big event and experience a hundred or more of your fellow players doing their best to play good Magic is an amazing thing.
Sure, you may lose to a Pact trigger or get ambushed by a takeback you’re no longer allowed to take. Trust me that these small travails are more than paid off by getting to experience the fun of technically strong play.
Creativity is fun
For some subset of the players at a PTQ, the event is a chance to showcase their latest creative effort. I’m definitely in this pool, and I often end up with an audience for my matches as a consequence.
Especially during an Extended season like this one, there’s a significant opportunity to see ideas that are either brand-new or that have simply been off the radar for a while. With roughly five thousand cards in the Extended card pool, even relatively small tweaks to existing archetypes can yield very different play experiences.
When I’m walking around the room after my match finishes each round, it’s only partially with an eye toward scouting potential opposition. Really, I’m on the lookout for what creative options, be they tweaks or entirely novel archetypes, people have brought to the PTQ.
Similarly, a PTQ is our opportunity to showcase your own creativity. If you’re new to PTQs, or new to Extended, you may not be especially excited about modifying a deck that you’ve just recently picked up for the event. That said, even small changes can throw your opposition off their game. Conley has offered a good discussion about the value of exercising creativity in deck choices. If you remember an excellent Mirrodin card from your EDH deck that you think would really work well in your Zoo sideboard, go for it. The existing deck lists are not so thoroughly proven as to obviate innovation.
I want to go, but
If I’ve fired you up about going to a PTQ, you still may have some doubts about getting involved in the current PTQ season. Here’s some quick advice on how to get up and running in what may feel like an expansive and intimidating format.
Getting set for Extended
Extended is a pretty big pool to dive into. With some five thousand cards to pull from it offers a host of viable archetypes. With that in mind, here’s my advice for a quick start.
First, you want to get an overview of what’s going on in Extended. Zaiem previews the current Extended season in this article, and reviews a whole bunch of significant Extended rules situations here. You’ll want to understand what decks are actually being played, which means you’ll need to go to my article
about building your Extended reference library.
Second, you need to step back, take a breath, and relax. Extended is a big, intimidating format, and the honest truth is that no one can keep all of that junk in their head. There is a non-zero chance that you will run into a deck you’ve never heard of before that does something you’ve never seen before. Before that happens, you’ll want to read my article about decision making during the game and Ben Stark’s excellent piece about knowing how your deck works.
Third, you need a deck. Extended is an expensive format, this is true. However, you may already own more of the cards you need than you realize. If you know a decent pool of casual players, you may also be able to borrow across your group to kit one or more of you out with most or all of a decent Extended deck. From there, you’ll just need a few key card purchases to make some viable decks for the PTQ. Now might be a good time to reread some Rishadawn Pawnshop to get a feel for just what deckbuilding options you have to suit your personal budget.
Finally, you’ll need to find a PTQ. There used to be a list of all PTQs for the season, and now there’s a search interface that I’m not especially fond of. Reprinted below are Tom LaPille’s directions on how to use that interface to find a PTQ to attend:
1. Go to this website:
2. In the “Find a Qualifier Near You!” box, type “usa” or “” and click the little magnifying glass button.
3. Click on the link underneath “Enter your City and State/Province or Postal Code” that says “New! Search using event start and end dates.”
4. In the “Search From” field, put the Saturday of a weekend during the PTQ season when you might want to play a PTQ. In the “Through” field, put the Sunday of that same weekend.
5. Click on “Get Map” underneath all the search options.
6. Zoom out so you can see the entire United States, or whatever other area you are willing to travel to.
7. In the Results box underneath the map, the locations of all PTQs in the United States (or whatever other place you searched in) that will happen during that weekend will appear.
8. Repeat for each weekend you might want to play in a PTQ.
Despite the fact that I am nearly a shill for progress, I did prefer simply having a list.
I hope I’ve fired up some of you for the current PTQ San Juan season. I love PTQs, and as much as I may be proselytizing my way into ever-longer PTQs by talking more of you into coming, I want to see you all there.
38 thoughts on “In Development – You Should Play in a PTQ”
Do all PTQs use the Extended format? Or are they sometimes Constructed standard or even limited?
@blake Last season was sealed. Before that was standard.
This was a good article. I also agree the new feature is terrible. It’s so frustrating to use I keep putting it off and maywell miss a ptq because of it. Whoever is responsible for it needs to be reigned in and given a much smaller role with fewer choices
PTQ formats occur in seasons, where you’ll have about three months of a particular format. The current format is Extended. Before Extended, the format was Zendikar Sealed, and before that, it was Constructed Standard.
Bah. Beat to the punch.
Pingback: Tweets that mention In Development - You Should Play in a PTQ | ChannelFireball.com -- Topsy.com
A more accressible way to get tournament dates is using the official tournament search here: http://webapp.wizards.com/tournaments.aspx Directly connected to the DCI database (I suppose).
I never have more fun playing magic than I do at PTQs. I was at Seattle for the first one of the season, slinging Elves before they were retro-cool. And most people are having fun too. My first opponent was on the play, and went chrome mox exiling empty the warrens, mountain, simian spirit guide, blood moon. I went “forest, llanowar elves”. We both started laughing.
I’ll admit what I love about PTQ’s is the fact that it forces you to travel all the time. Ya know what I love being a road warrior trying to qualify for a spot on the PT. I think my best experience so far was when I T16’ed at the PTQ in mobile for PT San Diego (that also happens to be my best finish) and the feeling, and stories I got from that are indescribable. I’ll tell ya I’m looking forward to moving back to the ohio valley region, and attending PTQ’s with players that I know from Ohio, PA, NY, and Kentucky. If anything Magic is great for travel, and the games not too bad either 😉 Good luck fellow PTQ’ers
I will be playing in next PTQs (in formats I like), because I won the last one I played in. See you in San Diego!
The difference is that at a concert you are not forced to interact with the annoying people.
Most players will not have fun at a PTQ. They are expensive, have very top heavy prize support and are populated with people who are bitter cause they still havent qualified but think they should have.
If you want to get into competitive play, and have a group of friends to test with, then yes, PTQs can be fun. For a semi casual player a PTQ is a waste of money.
Alex, if you had the choice between a PTQ and a $10 Sealed with $2000 in prizes, which would you play in?
Excellent piece. I’m not the biggest fan of Daniel Pink’s theories on economic integrity, (So Ayn Rand) but the reference was excellent. I’m glad I saw this column on an independent site. I’ve written columns like this for magicthegathering.com, but I’ve never seen something so geared toward the “technically correct play is fun” crowd, which I am very much a part of.
Thanks for an wonderful read. Stay fresh.
I love PTQs as well, and unfortunately have a long way to drive to get to any of them. I live in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, and the nearest PTQs are generally 5 hours drive (Edmonton) or 6 hours (Calgary), and anything else is even further, 10+ hours (for instance this season the only two within a less than 16 hour driving distance are Calgary at 6 hours and Fargo, ND at 12 hours). Nonetheless I go anyway because I love the game, and they’re usually a lot of fun even if I don’t win. Good article all round.
I also agree that I much preferred the old school “PTQ list” that came each qualifying season, and that the current format seems like a serious step backward.
Thanks for the comments, everyone.
@The Wolf – I’m going to have to disagree with your assertion about interaction at concerts and tournaments. I’ve never been assaulted at a Magic tournament, but that sure has happened at a concert. I keep going to both, because PTQs and live music are both awesome, but there’s going to be jerks in any large group of people. It’s an unavoidable reality of going outside.
@EvilBernd – Thanks for the reminder about that link. I still wish they just had the old-time lists.
@Sucros – I love stories like that. Excellent.
One more thing — conveniently, Josh’s article this week addresses budget Extended decks:
Thanks for this article, I’m just starting to travel to competitive events, and this piece has me excited to go to a PTQ.
I completely agree with you on the “technically correct play is fun” part, I wish more people felt that way- I caught some flak at a Grand Prix Trial for not giving a guy a takeback when he miscalculated =P
@Rob — I would go with the format I want to play the most. I adore Extended, so an Extended PTQ wins over most other potential events for me. If it were the same format head-to-head in the same time slot, then I think the $2K is more “casual friendly” in the sense that it’s cheaper and the prizes stretch down farther. I otherwise expect the experiences to be very similar.
Don’t downplay the importance of teamdrafting. There are enough high level players at a PTQ (in most areas) that after a few rounds, there are very good teamdrafts to be found, lasting all the way through top 8.
Thanks for this… I’d never heard of the Pro Tour when I played in my first PTQ. I was just there for competitive-level fun. It’s sometimes easy to forget why we play.
Well written and useful. Thank you.
Can someone tell me info about GP Oakland.
I plan to go but the schedule on Wizards site was confusing.
Does the tournament start on friday and at what time?
4x Goblin Guide
4x Hellspark Elemental
3x Keldon Marauders
2x Mogg Fanatic
2x Boggart Ram Gang
4x Flames of The Blood Hand
4x Lava SPike
4x Lightning Bolt
4x Magma Jet
3x Rift Bolt
4x Shrapnel Blast
4x Tree of Tales
4x Great Furnace
4x Teetering Peaks
4x Blood Moon
2x Ghost Quarter
3x Relic of Progenitus
4x Smash to Smithereens
2x Pithing Needle
I swear, its as if every week there are 2-3 more competitive lists out there for this extended season… Im beggining to expect a different matchup every single game, and i find it more enjoyable that way.
@Jacob — Grand Prix events, including GP Oakland, take place on Saturday and Sunday. However, there are often GP Trials the afternoon before, and you can also register the afternoon before.
For GP Oakland specifically, here are the schedule elements I know:
Friday, 2pm-9pm: Registration (and maybe GP Trials?)
Saturday, 8-9:30am: Registration
Saturday, 10am: Tournament starts
Sunday, 10am: Day 2 begins
There’s probably going to be a PTQ on day 2 as well.
If you’re interested in going to a GP, you might want to try going to a GP Trial ahead of time, either near you or the day before the GP. If you win a GP Trial, you get three byes at the GP (a free win for each of the first thee rounds).
You can find GP Trials near you (if there are any) using the search engine I mentioned in my article.
There is alot of people playing Magic outside the US also. Feels like this article dont care about that.
@Hampa — Having never played Magic outside the U.S., I feel I’m unqualified to speak to the experience. I hope PTQs are fun the world over, but I think I’ll leave it to players from South and Central America, Asia, and Europe to speak to their PTQ experience.
This article is about getting people to play in PTQs and why they are fun.. How does its blanket statements not cover the world?
Great read, btw!
Nice article. Glad to hear the PTQ experience is still great. I’m just getting back into the game — the last PTQ I went to I took an anti-Necro white weenie deck with a bunch of pro-black knights and Unstable Mutations. Necro still shredded me but I had fun.
Great article. i am also just getting back into the game. My last PTQ was Odyssey Block Constructed, where I T8ed with a UG Threshold/Madness deck (Yeah Wild Mongrel’s!!) I hope to get to a few PTQ’s this year.
The link in the article doesn’t work in Firefox or Safari because it includes a tag. This is probably due to automatic replacement of newlines with br tags in your content management system and a stray newline in the article itself.
For those that can’t get the link to work copy and paste it into your browser or visit: http://tinyurl.com/yzrhhrn
I love a nice, competitive game. But the difference between a competitive game inside a PTQ and the same game with nothing on the line is just a matter of gambling.
I’m not a gambler.
I guess I don’t accept that paying the fee to enter into this prize mill is the only way to find a competitive game, or that the matches inside a PTQ provide that much more fun value than the ones outside.
Furthermore, while I don’t think Magic is more fun with takebacks, I do think it’s more fun when I don’t have to watch my opponent shuffle like they’re trying to get away with something. Where they won’t get penalized for not reminding me about my cards if it later turns out the text doesn’t say “may”. The introduction of money makes all that necessary, and a lot more floor rules too.
Find me a good competitive game though without high stakes and the baggage that comes with it, and then I’m on board.
Pingback: In Development - Progenitus is my Co-Pilot | ChannelFireball.com
Just found the site and am reading through all the info here. As a long time competitive player who’s been playing for 15+ years (10+ competitively) I like to read that things like “road warriors” attempting to Q still happens.
However I would like to point out that this doesn’t happen the world over. Or maybe it does happen in Europe, but definately not up here in the Great North of Canada.
PTQ’s are usually defined by where the largest populations of people will and can gather for events. Now, I’m from Nova Scotia, somewhere I’m sure many of you have never heard of. It’s the Eastern province of Canada, and we have a solid playerbase of about 200+ players, as you will see from just about every Pre-release and gameday, but only about 10-15 are really “Competitive.” For most of the folks around here, magic is just a hobby. Which is cool.
However, for the rest of us that would like to take our Magicing to the next level, we have been forced into Modo. Not because we don’t WANT to play real cards, it’s that we can’t. The nearest PTQ site used to be in Moncton (a 6 hour drive) and then recently that slot was cut from the PTQ schedule, so our closest spot is Montreal. (20+ hour drive each way) Not that modo is a BAD alternative, as many of us work/school so we can afford to draft 3-4 times per week and grind in that way. But places that have overly large areas and next to zero population (I live in the biggest Metropolis in the Atlantic Provinces of Canada and the population is only between 1-2 million peeps) I realize that it’s better in places like Toronto or Montreal, but both of those places are 20-30 hour drives away, and aren’t reachable to those of us on the East Coast. I know the simple answer is just “Move west,” but with marriages and jobs and other things that take priority over the whole “Play as much magic as possible,” that’s not really an option for most.
I often read about players touring around the US and knowing that with a car and a 5 hour drive in any direction, they can hit 3-5 PTQ sites. I hope you all know how lucky you are. 😀
Regardless, the site is amazing, the articles fantastic, and many props to the site designers!
Pingback: » In Development – Magic Effectiveness Project – Strength, In Your Words
Pingback: » In Development – Progenitus is my Co-Pilot
Pingback: » In Development – Magic Effectiveness Project – Strength, In Your Words
Pingback: » In Development – New Season’s Resolutions
Comments are closed.