In this article, I will rank all cards in Innistrad: Crimson Vow from high-to-low for the purpose of the first-pack, first-pick (P1P1) decision in draft, answering the question “which card would you first-pick?” for every conceivable booster pack. While this Crimson Vow pick order reflects P1P1, the card rankings (which are based entirely on my own evaluations) are also a reflection of raw power in a vacuum. However, you shouldn’t mindlessly follow this or any other ranking for an entire draft, as synergies matter and valuations change once you commit to an archetype.
If you haven’t done so yet, then check out my article on the 10 two-color archetypes in Crimson Vow Limited first. Based on the gold signpost uncommons, it sets the stage and provides context for the Limited format.