Careful Consideration – This Format is Juuust Right


Extended is like Goldilocks.

I’m not a big fan of smaller constructed formats like Block. On one hand, you get to play with cards that you would not otherwise be able to play with because there are generally stronger effects in larger formats like Standard, but that’s more than offset by the general lack of answers to strong, possibly linear strategies.

For example, Lorwyn block showcased a powerful linear mechanic (tribal), but after a short time it became clear that there was one tribal deck that was more powerful than the others, forcing the format to become so Faerie-centric that if you realistically wanted to win a PTQ, you had to be playing the only tier one deck in the format. You might be able to win with a tier two deck like Kithkin, but you were handicapping yourself by not running out the Bitterblossoms on turn two. And there were no effective answers to the deck. A handful of narrow but powerful answers can keep a format healthy, which is what block formats often lack.

An the other extreme, Vintage, has such powerful cards that the format has gravitated towards a core of cards that do whatever it is they are trying to do extremely well. You get to play the best card draw, the best mana acceleration, the best counterspells, and so on. And that’s fine, but there’s less room for innovation there as well. It’s not likely that you’re going to manufacture an entirely new deck archetype that is going to be tier one for two reasons. One, the format’s been around long enough that people have figured out the holes in the metagame and deckbuilding, and decks are more efficient and better-tuned as a result. Two, because the power level is so high, there’s not a lot of room for taking advantage of hidden synergies that exploit those inefficiencies, which stifles innovation.

I’m not saying Vintage is a bad format. It’s fine, it’s healthy, and has a pretty passionate following. But I find it to be a little too inbred for my tastes as well for the above reasons.

And that brings us to Extended, the happy medium.

Extended is really the perfect format, or as close to it as you’re going to get. You have a huge range of strategies, any of which can be viable and competitive, and are quite powerful. But unlike smaller formats, Extended also comes equipped with the tools to answer each of those powerful strategies, making sure things don’t get out of hand.

Affinity is a very powerful mechanic, allowing you to play free spells while abusing the Modular mechanic with Arcbound Ravager. We saw how degenerate the deck could be when it was in Standard and Block Constructed (even if Disciple had been banned), but in Extended, it’s just another deck. It’s a very good deck, but cards like Kataki, Path to Exile, and Ancient Grudge are all very effective at disrupting Affinity’s strategy. You can go down the list. Storm? There’s Canonist, now Silence, effective hand disruption, and so on. And there are so many powerful mechanics available to you in Extended that it’s certainly reasonable to innovate new uses for them, especially ones that have been forgotten and have fallen off the radar, allowing you to take advantage of holes in the ever-shifting metagame. [Very happy to have gotten the chance to dust off my Astral Slides and Lightning Rifts for one last romp last season. –Riki] It’s a dynamic, interesting format and one I find to be quite skill-intensive.

The next Constructed PTQ format will be Extended, and we have an upcoming Extended Pro Tour (complete with Extended PTQ on Saturday!), in case you’re wondering why there’s all this random Extended talk out of nowhere. Let’s take a look at the Extended format when we left it in April, the last time we had Extended PTQs.

First of all, be aware that Onslaught block will rotate out of the format when Zendikar becomes legal next month. So Pro Tour: Austin will feature an Extended format that runs from Mirrodin block to Zendikar.


What it loses: Fetchlands, Sulfuric Vortex
What it gains: Bloodbraid Elf, Lightning Bolt

The biggest change to the format will be the rotation of the fetchlands in Onslaught, leaving people with worse mana. Although I don’t see any way to realistically splash black and blue in the deck just to power up Tribal Flames, the same does not hold true for the three-color mana base for the Naya version. You take more damage off your Ravnica dual lands by just having them come into play untapped, but you still get to attack with Kird Apes and Wild Nacatls that are usually powered up.

Vortex is a loss, but the format evolved to move away from the more burn-heavy version that Adam Prosak played in Grand Prix: Los Angeles to a more creature-based version like the Ranger Zoo one that Bill Stark made popular. The Prosakian version ran four Vortex main as well as cards like Keldon Marauders, whereas Ranger Zoo was moving the Vortices to the side and sometimes cutting Marauder entirely to make room for Ranger of Eos and Woolly Thoctar.

The loss of fetchlands is not insignificant, however. Tarmogoyf is noticeably worse in the new Extended format, as getting a land into the graveyard actually takes some work now, instead of being something you could count on for sure. Naya Zoo decks weren’t playing sorceries so Tarmogoyf was usually a 3/4 (land, instant, creature), but when he’s downgraded to an expensive Kird Ape, he’s suddenly not as exciting. So decks will either have to find a way to put lands in the graveyard (not likely unless they force themselves to play bad cards like Terramorphic Expanse – which if I had to do that just to pump up Tarmogoyf, I would probably set myself on fire), live with the fact that he’s a 2/3, or play sorceries like Molten Rain or a tribal card like Tarfire. I’m not the biggest fan of either of those cards, but Molten Rain tends to be better in the early part of the season when people’s mana bases aren’t optimal.

Another very realistic possibility is that Zendikar, which seems to be land-themed, might have a not-horrible way to get lands to the graveyard, letting Tarmogoyf run free and wild. (There’s also a rumor that Zendikar could have something like enemy-colored fetchlands or something along those lines, but color me skeptical on that one.)


LSV wrote an entire article on this deck and sums things up pretty well. One thing I would like to point out (Kha in the comments made this point) – the lack of fetchlands makes Engineered Explosives less reliable for blowing up three-casting cost things like Woolly Thoctar.

Death Cloud/Life from the Loamy Decks

What it loses: Fetchlands, cycling lands, Ravenous Baloth
What it gains: Maelstrom Pulse
Viability: High.

Life from the Loam plus cycling lands is a pretty ridiculous engine, providing insane card advantage. With no cycling lands, Life from the Loam is probably going to sit in the binders for the time being, or will be played fairly (and really, why would you play anything fair in Extended)? Early Death Cloud builds did not play Loam (and played Garruk instead), and those decks were viable, so we’ll probably see the decks revert to that form. The Loam decks evolved to take advantage of the Loam/cycling engine because it was so good (particularly against Faeries), but the older versions should be fine.


What it loses: Nothing
What it gains: Lightning Bolt
Viability: High

This is pretty much the same old deck. Play free spells, play Master of Etherium and Arcbound Ravager and maybe a Cranial Plating, and smash noses. Affinity does get better on a couple of fronts:

1. With no fetchlands in the format, it becomes harder for decks to splash for Ancient Grudge.
2. Lightning Bolt allows the Affinity player to have a red answer to Kataki instead of a white answer (Path to Exile). Affinity wants to be playing blue (Master of Etherium, Thoughtcast) and red (some combination of Fatal Frenzy, Atog, and Shrapnel Blast) for sure. Having really only two colors it needs to rely on makes the mana a little better, and they can cut the white entirely if they want to, letting them play green (Ancient Grudge for the mirror) or black (Cranial Plating equipping at instant speed, Thoughtseize).

Mono-Red Burn, AKA “the Lightning Bolt deck”

What it loses: Sulfuric Vortex
What it gains: Lightning Bolt, Ball Lightning
Viability: Medium

People laugh at the burn deck because it just burns people and is a highly linear, non-resilient deck. Losing Sulfuric Vortex makes it tough to deal with any sort of life gain (Jitte, Loxodon Hierarch). They can play Everlasting Torment, but that doesn’t put a clock on the opponent the way Vortex does, and is much worse as a result. However, it does pick up yet another Lightning Bolt (this one being, you know”¦Lightning Bolt).

Ball Lightning is generally not that exciting in aggro decks these days because it comes into play, does its thing, and goes away, and decks have evolved where that strategy is just not viable anymore. Except this deck doesn’t care about that – it’s fine using a card to deal three damage because all the cards in the deck do three damage or more with the exception of Mogg Fanatic.

The disappearance of fetchlands has an interesting effect on this deck. Some decks like Zoo will take more damage off their lands, whereas more stable two-color mana bases will only have four shocklands for the burn decks to take advantage of. We’ll see how greedy people get with their mana, but if people aren’t doing six to themselves each game (which was usually the case in last year’s format), then the addition of another Lightning Bolt will probably not be enough.


What it loses: Birchlore Ranger, Wirewood Symbiote
What it gains: Elvish Archdruid
Viability: Low

It’s possible that the deck that dominated Pro Tour: Berlin will adjust, but the losses of Symbiote and Birchlore Ranger are pretty big. The deck could adapt to be more like the Standard version, but it would be slower and more inconsistent. It might be able to sneak up on a PTQ field that isn’t ready for it, but this deck goes from “the most powerful deck in the format” to “gimmicky combo deck that can catch people by surprise.” You have better things to do with your time than play Elves.


What it loses: Mind’s Desire, Fetchlands, Tendrils of Agony
What it gains: Irrelevant
Viability: Extinct

No Mind’s Desire means no deck.

Astral Slide

What it loses: Astral Slide, cycling lands
What it gains: Irrelevant
Viability: Extinct

No cycling mechanic or Astral Slide means no deck.


What it loses: Fetchlands, Decree of Justice, Eternal Dragon
What it gains: Sanguine Bond? Baneslayer Angel?
Viability: Medium

Martyr’s actually much better positioned than it was last year. Martyr lost any matchup where the opponent’s late game was better than Martyr’s, because the deck was guaranteed to get to that late game by virtue of not actually doing anything relevant except not dying for the first dozen or so turns. So when a deck has Riptide Laboratory + Venser, or Life from the Loam + cycling lands + Raven’s Crime, then Martyr would just lose. Since both of those are out, Martyr’s jumped up on the rankings of “best late game in Extended.” Death Cloud + Garruk is still better, as is Mindslaver lock, so if those decks are popular, then Martyr is a poor choice. It’s a metagame deck, but a potentially powerful one. Sulfuric Vortex was another way aggro decks could randomly beat Martyr, and that card is also out of the format as well.

With Eternal Dragon and Decree out of the format, the deck has to find a new way to end games. Neither Sanguine Bond nor Baneslayer Angel fight through countermagic the way the other finishers do, so dipping into black for some sort of hand disruption before going off might be right, but maybe too slow, especially with the mana bases being worse with the lack of fetchlands.

The Unknown

There’s certainly room to break Extended. Cascade is the biggest culprit, and people have already tried to break it with the Hypergenesis combo deck (cascade into Hypergenesis, then the deck puts enormous creatures into play like Hellkite Overlord, Akroma, and Darksteel Colossus). The deck’s not very resilient and I don’t think it’s very good, but I like the idea.

In Time Spiral they printed a cycle of cards that had no converted mana cost but had suspend costs to make them reasonable (Lotus Bloom, Ancestral Visions, Restore Balance, Hypergenesis, Wheel of Fate, Living End). So you can build a deck to cascade into only those spells. If Ardent Plea is essentially casting Balance, how powerful is that deck? Even a deck that can reliably cascade into Ancestral Recall seems pretty strong. And who knows what else people are going to figure out what to cascade into. Playing spells for free is still good. Storm, Affinity, and Dredge (with Narcomoeba, Dread Return, Bridge From Below and friends) are some of the most broken mechanics we’ve seen. Cascade is right along those lines and with a card pool as large and as powerful as Extended’s, that mechanic is begging to be busted.

There are also combo decks to be had, which fill an important role in keeping the metagame balanced. Dragonstorm (powering out Hellkite Overlords or maybe Kokusho) might be the best use [I prefer the Bogardan Hellkite/ Karrthus, Tyrant of Jund build. -Riki], or someone could make the Hypergenesis deck actually good, or some off-the-wall thing using Jon Loucks’s suggestion of using Krark-Clan Ironworks and Open the Vaults will emerge. If you have a linear, powerful strategy, it can be disrupted; but if nobody’s ready for it, then you’re very well-poised, as we saw with Pro Tour: Berlin or even Grand Prix: Los Angeles.

I’m really anticipating the Zendikar spoiler, as some of the rumored cards and mechanics, if true, would have a bigger effect on Extended deckbuilding than most sets. It may be that by the time this goes up, they’ve spoiled enemy-color fetchlands, Counterspell, and reprinted the cycling lands (all of which are rumors I’ve heard), and we have to re-evaluate how we approach the format.

All I know is that I can’t wait to dust off my Ravnica dual lands.

Yours shockingly,

zaiemb at gmail dot com

30 thoughts on “Careful Consideration – This Format is Juuust Right”

  1. Extended is like Goldilocks if Goldilocks was Marissa Miller, Heidi Klum and Rebecca Romjin rolled into one….

    I <3 porridge..

  2. Great job as usual. I always enjoy your articles.

    Just curious what your thoughts were on the Thopter Foundry/Sword of the Meek/Time Seive extended deck?

  3. Alexander Ferdynus

    Extended is my favourite format also, but for a different reason.

    Standard is bland and top decks are easily $200-300 for only a year or two.

    Vintage/Legacy is far too expensive for my taste (granted I love reading about those games).

    Extended is expensive (mana base of about $100-200 although come rotation this will subside slightly) but you get 3-7 years out of most cards (I’m looking at you shocklands).

    Eggs was my favourite deck post rotation, and it’s still together, with the death of TEPS (a far better combo deck) maybe eggs will comeback? (watch your metagame). Certainly the lack of Ancient Grudge will be nice to eggs. If they reprint counterspell in zendikar I’d wager that control will be pretty hard to get past.

    Finally, the coolest thing about extended, no matter what the top decks are, usually half the decks being played are Zoo. Picking a deck that crushes zoo isn’t a bad idea IMHO. Unless it’s another zoo build 😉

  4. Pretty sure a standard legal Elf Combo deck won a huge LEGACY tournament at Gen Con, so watch out. I am positive that deck exists in extended too. I am just putting that out there…

  5. I was almost expecting you to write what Unknown was losing. (doesn’t know extended formats very well so expected unknown to be a deck)

  6. If enemy-color fetchlands would be printed in Zendikar i think that would be a big annoyance. I did not like the fact that every deck could splash colors as it pleased thanks to the ridiculous fixing fetches and duals provided.

    Legacy is like Vintage a pretty slow changing and stale format. There are more different strategies but still it is hardly affected by new sets unless there is a pretty sick card or a combo piece some decks have just been wating for. Extended usually is affected by new Sets on a bigger scale because the card pool is just big enough to not be completely warped around but still small enough to have the need to adapt. It is my favourite format because of this. Only let down is that there are not many tournaments besides PTQs.

  7. I agree with Jon that Legacy is strictly better. It’s healthier, more diverse, has greater rewards to forward thinkers, involves much higher strategic depth, presents more problems while simultaneously presenting more answers to those problems, and still avoids the borderline stagnant brokenness of Vintage (i.e. some cards are so broken that their presence pushes certain strategies and cards out because they can’t hope to compete on any level).

    That said, it’s also much more expensive. I honestly feel that a printing of Enemy Fetch Lands would be great for the format in that regard though because it will finally allow people to bypass Dual Lands (and their price tag) to a certain extent and finally allow BASIC lands to actually show up on lists in higher numbers than 2 or 3 while still maintaining perfectly healthy manabases.

  8. Obviously TEPS is dead, but I don’t think storm as a whole is out. Dragonstorm, Spinerock Knoll, and many of the TS block standard storm decks get a lot of new toys now that Mind’s Desire no longer dominates the situation.

    I will be interested to see what bygone era standard decks get now that they can slide Heartbeat into the build and see what happens.

    As long as people don’t run the new storm killer from Zendikar -.-

  9. I don’t know that getting red rather than white answers really opens up Affinity’s mana base that much (particularly considering Darkblast was already the card of choice for dealing with Kataki). Since the deck is typically running 2 Blinkmoth Nexus and 16 Artifact Lands (though some versions did run 1-2 City of Brass or Glimervoid), a URwb base is trivially more stable than URb) thanks to the 8 pack of stars and drums.

  10. Um, did you mean to lead off your article by saying that Extended is like warm porridge and comfortable beds? It’s not like Goldilocks. Goldilocks was a whiny, picky, greedy, thieving bitch, and entirely out of her freaking mind. What kind of psycho goes into a house owned by BEARS, steals their stuff, and sleeps in their beds? Extended isn’t at all messed up like that little nutcase. It’s much more like the tasty food and free place to rest she unabashedly stole.

  11. On the death cloud deck. Without fetches and cyclers, the deck is in the same position as the rock was before extended rotated for the first time. You just don’t have a reliable tutor or engine to find the cards you need. Striking the balance between cards that fix your mana, affect the board, and attack your opponent’s hand without getting stuck with useless cards at the wrong time seems like a lot of work. All you end up with is a midrange deck; we know how fond of those some writers are.

    Just a point of pride, but there was a death cloud loam deck before Garruk was printed. Two people played it, and we both qualified.

  12. Jacob Van Lunen wrote about a Cascade/Restore Balance deck in his Building on a Budget article a few weeks back. I built it and tested. The thing actually works very well with great consistency. Only issues are either drawing a Balance, which weakens all your Cascade draws, or having to topdeck a March of the Machines or Phyrexian Totem, post-Balance, FTW. Attacking with a triple-Exalted Totem is pretty funny. Leaving your opponent with no lands, creatures, or cards in hand is always money.

    Anyways…great article. Very insightful! Keep’em coming.

  13. Nope it’s just like Goldilocks as in it steals a ptq and pt format every year from better formats like team sealed and even block (sometimes)

  14. Zaiem,

    Are you building Martyr-Proc. I really liked your/Jon Loucks’ build from last year, but w/out fetches, it seems like Phyrexian Arena is a nil possibility. Anychance you could email or facebook me with a list, assuming you have one.

    I’ll send you a facebook friend request anyway.


  15. ok goyf. we got other ways of geting a land in the grave. like lightning storm ( you know i had to) and country side crusher. one green cycleing card and the loam its self dredged. what realy gets a kick is dredge now can come back.

  16. “, and still avoids the borderline stagnant brokenness of Vintage”

    lol. Legacy never changes. The format hasn’t changed since GP: Chicago, other than Firespout got a wee bit better. The only major change over the past few years was the rise of CB/Top over normal Thresh decks.

  17. Also not a fan of legacy’s counter top with free counterspells or combo choice of decks. I would put money on dredge or dragonstorm being hot for a week (or one pt) then blue decks dominating. This is, ofcourse, under the assumption that there are no fetchlands come zen. For the record i hope there are no fetch lands so decks can have some constraints other than life total.

  18. Good article, Zaiem, though I’m saddened by no mention of Tron 🙁 I think it’ll be very good next season, unless anathemancer ends up being everywhere.

    To those commenting about Legacy… It’s absolutely false that the metagame hasn’t changed since Chicago, though I understand it may appear that it hasn’t to those who don’t follow the format. Yes, CB Top is still the best deck in the format, but it’s not the best deck by a particularly wide margin. There’s a large slew of tier one decks right now spread across aggro, control, combo, and aggro-control so you can really play whatever sort of deck you want.

    And Legacy is very much affected by new printings. Wild Nacatl, Qasali Pridemage, and Knight of the Reliquary have pushed Zoo into tier 1 status while the merfolk tribe from Lorwyn allowed Merfolk to become a tier 1 deck. Sower of Temptation and Vendilion Clique are widely played creatures, Path to Exile sees play, and many more. The new printings greatly affect the format, and it’s one of the only formats in existence where there are more than 20 viable decks. Standard certainly doesn’t have that diversity.

  19. AAARRGH….

    Getting the fetchlands rotated was one of the biggest hopes I had for Extended to stop being a 3+ color madness similar to Standard with Vivids. Now we have another guaranteed 3 years of this. So, to sum it up, nothings changes, except Elfball, TEPS and Slide leave while 4-5 color aggro and 4-5 color control take an even bigger piece of the cake.

    If only a R Humility for nonbasic lands appeared in Zendikar…

  20. One thing that was missed about Affinity:
    It lost combat damage on the stack. As a former Affinity player, this is quite significant. It may be more significant a loss than any other deck in any format (except other format’s Affinity decks).

  21. Fetchlands!

    Anyway, it’d have been nice to have discussed some kind of tron deck. U/G, U/B, U/W or even U/R all look quite plausable?

    Gifts Ungiven’s sure to show up somewhere too, isn’t it?

  22. Pingback: Careful Consideration - Midrange Melange | ChannelFireball.com

  23. Pingback: MTGBattlefield

  24. Pingback: » Careful Consideration – Midrange Melange

  25. Pingback: » Careful Consideration – Midrange Melange

Comments are closed.

Scroll to Top