I arrived in San Jose yesterday and it’s as amazing as I thought it would be. The weather may not be as warm as I would have thought it would be in California, but it is much better than below freezing! After a night of testing Standard with the crew down here, I realized I didn’t know as much about the format as I hoped. The Grand Prix this weekend is another story. I feel good about Extended. Here’s what I’ll be playing:
I know this isn’t an ordinary Zoo list. Most of the decisions that went into this list are designed to help it compete against Dark Depths and Zoo mirrors. I found the shell of this list in one of the “Decks of the Week” from Wizards.
The reason I want good match ups against Depths and Zoo is because they are the only Tier 1 decks in the format. There are many decks available, but when it comes to sheer power and consistency, these decks keep taking home the victories. After you find something that has an edge in both these match ups, however, you still need to be able to compete with the rest of the field.
This is where this list shines. Ranger of Eos isn’t what most people would consider a main deck spell. He is really good against the Zoo mirror, but can fall short in some of the other match-ups out there. I can’t even begin to argue how much I hate drawing him against any of the fast combo decks, but he isn’t too bad against some of the control decks in the environment.
While Ranger is bad, though, the other new additions thrive. Against non-Dredge combo decks in this format, Woolly Thoctar and Negate are really good. Thoctar might cost three mana, but he packs a punch not many can follow. Games end rather even without the aggressive curve of Domain Zoo.
I’ll go over the match ups to give you an idea how some games play out.
There are two ways Zoo mirrors usually go. In one way, a player gets an early lead with a few of their best beaters and has a removal spell for every creature his opponent plays, while his opponent is removal light. Games can be won with this type of tempo, but most end up as big attrition wars. It isn’t surprising that two decks running 20-some creatures and 12 to 16 removal spells would get into this situation.
The advantage this deck has in the mirror match is that most of its spells are better than average against it’s opponents. Only one removal spell doesn’t kill any creature on the board, while most lists run Lightning Bolt, Lightning Helix, or Tribal Flames. This means there are less chances to have dead removal against a big creature.
The other thing that is nice about this list is that it has eight powerful three-drops. Woolly Thoctar outclasses every creature in the Zoo match up except Knight of the Reliquary and Baneslayer (if people are still running her). Having a bunch of creatures that pack a bigger punch starts making your opponents two-for-one themselves to deal with the threats you present. Once the game slows down a bit, clear card advantage will show through, giving you more options than your opponent.
Negate isn’t the strongest in the mirror match. I have definitely won some games on the back of that card, but it is only good when you have it late and you’re both in a close top-deck war. The problem with this scenario is that any piece of creature removal is probably better at that point.
After sideboarding, this 60 is really good against most generic Zoo lists. Ranger + Jiite are really strong at winning the long game. Plus, the deck has enough early game to get to the point where you can drop true threats. Against Domain Zoo it is really important to remember that you are the control player in this match up. Damage prevention is important. The easiest way to lose is if they get too far ahead on the board or in the damage race.
Dark Depths Thopter Combo
This matchup is really interesting. This version of Zoo has a tougher time simply running over the competition, but it has a high number of spells that answer most of DD’s threats. Negate is really good at slowing them down for a turn since they usually only play one spell a turn. Bant Charm kills both sides of the combo, which makes it a very valuable piece of removal.
It’s hard to explain how this matchup plays out since it always is dependent on how your opponent wants to play it. You are going to try to get a few creatures on the board and attack, while using your spells to help control the game. Keeping a hand with some disruption is good, but if you find an aggressive draw on the play you cannot mulligan it for removal. Negate will usually not be a surprise since they do play a lot of hand disruption and should see it coming.
This is how I sideboard for game two if I do not know what style of deck they will turn into. It has a few more answers to either problem and a much better curve at attacking. I don’t like having to take out Bolt since Dark Confidant is such a powerful spell in their deck, but something has to come out and you still have eight removal spells for him and Marit Lage.
If your opponent boarded into a very controlling UB deck and took out some copies of either one or both combos, I would gauge that and if you get another game against him bring back in a few Rangers. Some Depths players find that if their Zoo opponent is going to dilute their deck to the point that getting multiple threats on the board is difficult, they will play a bad control deck. Ranger will help fight the attrition war they want to play.
Meddling Mage is an important tool in this match up. It is hard to decide what the best card to name is, but I can guarantee any spell can be named. Don’t be afraid to not name a combo piece. Sometimes when you are holding Path to Exile, naming Muddle the Mixture is your only way to win. This can stop the DD player from countering your only piece of removal.
Red Deck Wins
This is an important match up to learn. It is mostly dependent on you which deck wins. Figuring out how to stay aggressive while deciding whether to fetch basics or tapped lands is difficult. You don’t want to take much damage from your lands, but sometimes it isn’t that bad since [card]Negate[/card] can give you a turn you wouldn’t have had before.
This isn’t much of a sideboard, but it isn’t that important since the odds are in your favor if you play correctly.
Negates really help against Scapeshift. Before, it was hard to decide when the correct game plan was to Path their creatures, but now it is an easy decision when you have a Negate. I have lost a few games to double Punishing Fire + Groves, but that will happen to the deck anyways. It is important to stay aggressive against Scapeshift since they are basically an aggro deck with four “I win” cards.
I bring in two Jittes since they will try to win games on the back of their own Jittes. Meddling Mage is a great card here – use it to name good cards like Bloodbraid Elf the turn before they can play him, or Scapeshift itself in the late game when they do not have removal left in hand.
Do not be afraid to use Path to Exile against this deck. It may give them the chance to combo a turn faster, but if you don’t kill their creature with an efficient piece of removal you won’t be able to get through the Finks and Goyfs fast enough to kill them.
Well this is one of the toughest match ups you’ll play. It’s so tough I decided to find four slots to hate it even when I don’t know how big it will be in the metagame. I don’t know why I have the scare right now, but I think Dredge has a chance to come back again for this Grand Prix. The hate isn’t there anymore and everyone is worrying about other decks. I don’t even know if four cards in the sideboard are enough to defeat Dredge, but since I find it more important to have them than anything else they are there to stay.
This is another relatively difficult deck to beat. The first game is much harder, but a lucky Negate with some pressure can quickly mop them up. Try to deal with Heritage Druids the moment they hit play. Nothing good can come from them having that creature.
I don’t know if I have sideboard for this matchup correct yet, but this is what I have been doing. Negate and Bant Charm are good at times, but sometimes they’re terrible. They’re never good in multiples. Since we are bringing in more removal, it’s important to keep in a few of each, but take out the extras. The obvious strategy post-board is to get a Jitte and start bashing. Elves may be really good at winning against no hate, but if you have a Meddling Mage and an active Jitte they lose quickly.
Like I said earlier, this deck list isn’t the best list out there, but is the best at the job I want it to do. I like having a list with advantages against the mirror and Dark Depths and this does that. If anyone is going to the Grand Prix this weekend, check out the ChannelFireball booth. I’ll be hanging out there from time to time and would like to meet anyone daring enough to pick this list up and battle with it the next day. Good luck!
FFfreaK on MTGO